Negroni, Spritz, Moscow Mule: who really invented these cocktails?
Every famous cocktail has its inventor, its date and its anecdote. The archives, for their part, yield a letter, a few press cuttings and a great deal of silence. In between, there was often someone with an ingredient to sell.
On 13 October 1920, a London correspondent by the name of Harper wrote to Count Camillo Negroni in Florence. His letter speaks of a mixture that already bears the name of its recipient, and jokingly warns him against excess. That is all. For twenty-seven years, no other known document names the Negroni.
Famous cocktails all have a birth certificate, with a place, a date and an inventor. The question is who drew it up, and when.
Florence, around 1919: the count and the barman
The story is well known. In the aftermath of the First World War, at the Caffè Casoni in Florence, Camillo Negroni (1868-1933), an aristocrat who had lived in America, is said to have asked the barman Fosco Scarselli to strengthen his “Americano”, a mixture of bitter and red vermouth topped up with soda water, by replacing the water with gin. The Florentine barman Luca Picchi devoted a book to this story, Sulle tracce del conte, and it was he who published the 1920 letter. It proves that the drink existed and bore that name at that date. It says nothing about the recipe, the café or the barman.
The cocktail historian David Wondrich points to the gap that follows: after 1920, the Negroni vanishes from the sources and only resurfaces in 1947, in Rome, in the cafés of the Via Veneto. A French collection of 1929 did publish an identical mixture, under the name “Campari mixte”; nothing says it came from Florence. The earliest printed recipes under the name Negroni so far identified date from 1955, in England. They described three equal parts of gin, vermouth and bitter.
The story also has its counter-story. One branch of the family disputes that Camillo held the title of count, and a Corsican tradition attributes the invention to General Pascal-Olivier de Negroni (1829-1913), who is said to have created it at Saint-Louis in Senegal around 1857. The date runs into a simple obstacle: Gaspare Campari's bitter did not appear until 1860. What the family claims is, at best, a different vermouth mixture.
Veneto, nineteenth century: soldiers and water
The Spritz has an even vaguer origin, and that may be why it convinces. From 1815 to 1866, Veneto belonged to the Austrian Empire. Soldiers and officials from the north, used to beer, are said to have had the local wines, which they found too strong, topped up with water — the word would come from the German spritzen, “to splash”. The Oxford Companion to Spirits and Cocktails repeats this explanation, but no period source it cites reports it. It is a tradition, consistent with the language, not an established fact.
Aperol, on the other hand, has a firm date: it was launched in Padua in 1919 by the Barbieri family. The mixture of Aperol, sparkling wine and soda water appeared much later. The same Companion acknowledges that it is “difficult to establish when” bars on the Venetian coast began to use it, towards the end of the twentieth century. Its spread around the world followed the purchase of the brand by the Campari group in 2003, which turned it into the emblematic drink of an Italian summer. The Spritz that people take to be centuries old is, in its familiar form, a product of this century.
Hollywood, 1941: three salesmen in a bar
The Moscow Mule has the most precise birth certificate, and that is precisely what should put us on our guard. In 1948, the journalist Clementine Paddleford recounted in the New York Herald Tribune a scene from 1941: three men meet at the Chatham Hotel in New York. Jack Morgan, owner of the Cock 'n' Bull restaurant in Hollywood, is trying to get rid of his ginger beer. John G. Martin, of the Heublein company, and Rudolph Kunett have Smirnoff vodka to sell, which Americans were still shunning. The recipe published in 1948 combined two ounces of vodka, Morgan's ginger beer and lime juice.
The named inventors are thus the suppliers of two of the three ingredients. The first printed mentions of the name, in 1942, confirm that the drink was then circulating in Hollywood; they say nothing about how it was conceived. In 2007, the Wall Street Journal collected another version, that of Wes Price, a former barman at the Cock 'n' Bull, who said he had put the mixture together to clear an overstocked cellar.
That leaves the copper mug. The 1948 article already mentions an order for engraved mugs. But the story of Sophie Berezinski, a Russian immigrant who arrived with two thousand mugs made by her father's company and is said to have done the rounds of the bars of Los Angeles before pushing open the door of the Cock 'n' Bull, only appears in the twenty-first century. It was handed down by her descendants and by a company that sells these mugs today. No document from the period confirms it.
What the birth certificates say
All three stories follow the same rule: cocktails have no birth certificate; one is written for them after the fact, and often by those who had an ingredient to sell. The Negroni is attested in 1920 by a letter, and famous from 1947. The Aperol Spritz took hold after 2003. The Moscow Mule was recounted in 1948 by its own promoters. It is customary to mock legends; it is more useful to read the dates.
Bottles have met the same fate as glasses: their shapes too have been reassigned by the brands.